Question: In a german ubuntu guide for the hddtemp program is claimed that every S.M.A.R.T. request wakes up the drive although no data is read. Because some harddrives that can park their head into a parking position can do so only a certain number of times and will wear off earlier. I never heard or read about this before.
I wonder if the claim is true at all and why the head has to be put out of its parking position when only SMART is requested. The statement that only certain drives can actually park their head confuses me more, how do I confirm that my drives do or not? And will the once per minute request that hddtemp does really have a noticable effect on my drives? I mean they will die sooner or later anyway.
I’d also appreciate more sources on this topic than just a statement written to some wiki.
Answer: The problem you describe is real. It is true that most hard disks will break downonce a certain number of head-parkings are done.
For an official news as regarding at least the Western Digital’s line of Caviar Green hard disk drives, see this article : WD Caviar Green HDDs Suffer from a Critical Design Flaw, which discussesthe not-so-intelligent wonderful new IntelliPark feature of WD and how it destroys disks.
A long thread discusses this problem : WD Green Drives – BUYER BEWARE, startedby someone whose new WD Green Drive failed too soon and who discovered this problem,as well as a solution (for WD only).
As to the question of when does any hard disk park its heads, you will have to searchthe supplied documentation and/or ask their Support. The operating system can puta drive to sleep and wake it up, but doesn’t normally control the head-parking.This is done by the disk firmware, and may or may not be parametrableby a utility of the manufacturer (as is the case for WD).
I would assume, however, that a sleeping disk will park its head, so too manysleep cycles are to be avoided. A sleeping drive can probably not answer SMART requests,so insisting upon one will wake the drive up.
But again, different drives may behave differently.